Review Question - QID 218895

A 57-year-old businesswoman presents to your office with complaints of right foot pain which is located about her transverse arch. She states it feels like she is "stepping on a pebble," and she is able to further localize the tenderness to the plantar aspect of her 2nd metatarsophalangeal joint. She has attempted wearing wider toe box shoes, as her high heels tend to make the pain worse, but to this point nonoperative measures have not improved her pain. An MRI is ordered which demonstrates a degenerative plantar plate tear. Which of the following conditions is most likely to develop?