• BACKGROUND
    • Posterolateral tibial plateau impaction fractures occur frequently associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears. Some authors advocate operative treatment of high-grade impaction fractures, which has led to the development of classification systems. Our study aims (1) to describe and compare the intra- and interobserver reliability of the two most used classifications and (2) to assess correlations between the grade of bony posterolateral tibial injury, patient characteristics and short-to mid-term revision rate after ACL reconstruction.
  • MATERIALS AND METHODS
    • In a retrospective series of 163 patients who underwent ACL reconstruction, two reviewers independently evaluated the preoperative MRI scans. Conform the Menzdorf and Bernholt classification the presence and grade of an associated posterolateral impaction fracture were assessed. Statistical analyses were performed to test for both study hypotheses.
  • RESULTS
    • 171 primary ACL cases were evaluated. Mean follow-up time was 41 months (range 12-154, SD = 17.1). Mean age was 32 years (range 13-59, SD = 12). Posterolateral impaction fractures were present in 111 (64.9 %) and 120 (70.0 %) cases, according to the Menzdorf and Bernholt classification. A Segond fracture was present in 19 (11.1 %) cases. Kappa value was 0.47 for intra- and 0.52 for the interobserver reliability for the Menzdorf classification (moderate reliability). For the Bernholt classification kappa values were 0.66 and 0.61, respectively (good reliability). A Segond fracture correlated significantly with the presence of a posterolateral impaction fracture (p < 0.05). A significant association was present between patients necessitating ACL revision surgery and patients for whom operative intervention for the posterolateral impression was advised following the Menzdorf classification (p < 0.001).
  • CONCLUSION
    • Inter- and intraobserver reliability testing for classifying posterolateral tibial fractures resulted in moderate to good reliability. High-grade posterolateral tibial fractures should be identified, selective treatment should be considered as they are associated with higher revision rates after ACL reconstruction if left untreated.